Below is a consensus ranking for the top dynasty players as determined by our very knowledgeable forum participants. For each position, we began by voting on the #1 player and once a consensus was reached we moved on to #2, etc. Within each list, there are links which will take you to the individual thread for that vote. This is where you can find debates for that particular player (and others) and read the reasoning behind why people voted they way they did. I’m sure you will find the information useful in your upcoming drafts and when making those tough trade decisions. A BIG thanks to everyone who took the time to participate… without you these rankings would not have been possible.
Quarterbacks | Running Backs | Wide Receivers | Tight Ends
1T. Tom Brady
1T. Peyton Manning (thread here)
3. Tony Romo (thread here)
4. Drew Brees (thread here)
5. Ben Roethlisberger (thread here)
6. Carson Palmer (thread here)
7. Derek Anderson (thread here)
8. David Garrard (thread here)
9. Jay Cutler (thread here)
10. Matt Hasselbeck (thread here)
11. Donovan McNabb (thread here)
12. Marc Bulger (thread here)
13. Eli Manning (thread here)
14. Matt Schaub (thread here)
15. Philip Rivers (thread here)
Quarterbacks | Running Backs | Wide Receivers | Tight Ends
1. Adrian Peterson (thread here)
2. Steven Jackson (thread here)
3. LaDainian Tomlinson (thread here)
4. Brian Westbrook (thread here)
5. Joseph Addai (thread here)
6. Frank Gore (thread here)
7. Marshawn Lynch (thread here)
8. Clinton Portis (thread here)
9. Maurice Jones-Drew (thread here)
10. Willis McGahee (thread here)
11. Reggie Bush (thread here)
12. Marion Barber III (thread here)
13. Larry Johnson (thread here)
14. Michael Turner (thread here)
15. Ronnie Brown (thread here)
16. Ryan Grant (thread here)
17. Rashard Mendenhall (thread here)
18. Darren McFadden (thread here)
19. Jonathan Stewart (thread here)
20. Laurence Maroney (thread here)
21. Brandon Jacobs (thread here)
22. Jamal Lewis (thread here)
23. Kevin Smith (thread here)
24. Ernest Graham (thread here)
25. Matt Forte (thread here)
Quarterbacks | Running Backs | Wide Receivers | Tight Ends
1. Randy Moss (thread here)
2. Reggie Wayne (thread here)
3. Andre Johnson (thread here)
4T. Braylon Edwards
4T. Larry Fitzgerald (thread here)
6. Marques Colston (thread here)
7. Steve Smith (thread here)
8. Brandon Marshall (thread here)
9. Chad Johnson (thread here)
10. Terrell Owens (thread here)
11. Anquan Boldin (thread here)
12. TJ Houshmandzadeh (thread here)
13. Calvin Johnson (thread here)
14. Roy Williams (thread here)
15. Santonio Holmes (thread here)
16. Torry Holt (thread here)
17. Greg Jennings (thread here)
18. Wes Welker (thread here)
19T. Dwayne Bowe
19T. Plaxico Burress (thread here)
21. Roddy White (thread here)
22. Lee Evans (thread here)
23. Jerricho Cotchery (thread here)
24T. Anthony Gonzalez
24T. Santana Moss (thread here)
Quarterbacks | Running Backs | Wide Receivers | Tight Ends
1. Jason Witten (thread here)
2. Antonio Gates (thread here)
3. Kellen Winslow, Jr. (thread here)
4. Chris Cooley (thread here)
5. Tony Gonzalez (thread here)
6. Dallas Clark (thread here)
7. Todd Heap (thread here)
8. Vernon Davis (thread here)
9. Owens Daniels (thread here)
10. Tony Scheffler (thread here)
11. Heath Miller (thread here)
12T. Ben Watson
12T. Greg Olsen
12T. Jeremy Shockey (thread here)
on this post - (11) Posts 
Loading ...
Loading ...