| User | Post |
|
7:50 pm
May 28, 2008
|
X
Moderator
| | | |
|
| posts 6205 |
|
|
Tony Romo has won the vote for the #3 dynasty QB according to the members of this forum. Assuming standard scoring, who is your vote for #4?
Top Dynasty QB
1T. Tom Brady
1T. Peyton Manning (thread here)
3. Tony Romo (thread here)
|
|
|
7:53 pm
May 28, 2008
|
dmac37
Rookie
| | | |
|
| posts 94 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
8:07 pm
May 28, 2008
|
Hambone
Elite User
| | Ontario | |
|
| posts 1702 |
|
|
|
8:08 pm
May 28, 2008
|
Gambler
Elite User
| | Pacific NW | |
|
| posts 1195 |
|
|
|
8:12 pm
May 28, 2008
|
Wutthecrapman
Stud
| | Montreal | |
|
| posts 344 |
|
|
Carson Palmer
2008 was considered a BAD year. It might be better if his receivers care to play to there potenial.
Sometimes it's all not about the arm, it's the total package. I find Carson is that smart QB. He's healthy young too.
I'd pick Big Ben if he puts up back to back years. Brees would have been there if he did'nt tank it inthe first half of last year.
|
|
|
8:12 pm
May 28, 2008
|
B D O
Elite User
| | New Orleans | |
|
| posts 1173 |
|
|
|
8:15 pm
May 28, 2008
|
Starstruck
Stud
| | Oklahoma | |
|
| posts 255 |
|
|
|
8:23 pm
May 28, 2008
|
PAFAS
Elite User
| | Atlanta, GA | |
|
| posts 631 |
|
|
You know, that's a damn good question that we all wish we had the answer to. Imo outside of the top three spots you've got 3 or 4 legit Qb's that we can make a good case for.
Carson - if the spoiled brat and pretty boy could play to half their talent they could be the best passing team in the league. not my pick
Big Ben - they have a lot of talented receivers in the Burg these days but he's not my pick either
Derek Anderson - he's young, he had an outstanding season last year but i can't see him doing to much better then he did (well…maybe not)
My pick is Brees - From what I've seen a lot of people have him way lower then the 4 spot. Which is fine with me cause thats were I'll slide in. He was tossin the rock mighty well towards the end of the year last season. He's got one extremely talented receiver in Colston and a handful of young aggressive players to go along (excluding Bush the bust). Plus they throw a lot. A whole lot.
|
|
|
8:24 pm
May 28, 2008
|
Dolemite
Elite User
| | | |
|
| posts 638 |
|
|
|
8:29 pm
May 28, 2008
|
Jaysports
Elite User
| | Denver, CO | |
|
| posts 598 |
|
|
|
8:33 pm
May 28, 2008
|
kethnaab
Elite User
| | | |
|
| posts 1344 |
|
|
Wutthecrapman said:
Carson Palmer
2008 was considered a BAD year. It might be better if his receivers care to play to there potenial.
Sometimes it’s all not about the arm, it’s the total package. I find Carson is that smart QB. He’s healthy young too.
I’d pick Big Ben if he puts up back to back years. Brees would have been there if he did’nt tank it inthe first half of last year.
actually, it was only the first 4 games. He threw 13 TDs in the next 5 games.
Drew Brees, #4 Dynasty QB
|
|
|
8:37 pm
May 28, 2008
|
Hinche
Elite User
| | The Desert | |
|
| posts 556 |
|
|
|
|
|
palmer…weapons aside he is simply a more talented player…
|
|
|
9:14 pm
May 28, 2008
|
Starstruck
Stud
| | Oklahoma | |
|
| posts 255 |
|
|
PAFAS said:
(excluding Bush the bust).
Well thats a little harsh……. As far as rankings go Bush helps the stats of any qb throwing the rock to him. I don't want to get off track on this thread but Bush(in ppr leagues) was a top 10 back his rookie year and a top 12 back in year 2(after missing 4 games).
Bust……… I think not.
Disclaimer: If you are in a nonppr league, just ignore this post
|
|
|
9:44 pm
May 28, 2008
|
WKTSWAY
Rookie
| | Shakopee, MN | |
|
| posts 128 |
|
|
Going with Big Ben again.
|
|
|
9:55 pm
May 28, 2008
|
rotobradley
Elite User
| | Kansas City, MO | |
|
| posts 1844 |
|
|
|
9:57 pm
May 28, 2008
|
X
Moderator
| | | |
|
| posts 6205 |
|
|
Brees again for me.
Brees 11
Palmer 3
Rothy 1
|
|
|
10:01 pm
May 28, 2008
|
JohnnyD
Rookie
| | | |
|
| posts 53 |
|
|
Ben Roethlisberger
If you throw away the accident year Big Ben has gotten better each year. Palmer has gotten worse each year since the Bengals peaked in 2005. Ben's QB rating is higher than Palmers. While the entire WR corp for Cinn is sitting at home, Roethlisberger has more weapons this year than last year, a solid running game with Parker & Mendy and adding Sweed to Ward & Holmes (Breakout year IMO)…even Moore is a good wr out of the backfield. Palmers only advantage is that they have no def and will have to play catch up every game, but with Ben's schedule this year Pittsburgh will have to put up points.
Brees has been nothing but consistent and is the safe pick.
But being a Steelers fan and looking to upside, gotta go Roethlisberger.
|
|
|
10:05 pm
May 28, 2008
|
Wutthecrapman
Stud
| | Montreal | |
|
| posts 344 |
|
|
All true Kethnaab but like Evans, if you don't show up in 4 games in fantasy games you go under the inconsistant column and owner get nervous. He was Rex Grossman like.
What happens if Colston goes down? The other boys have other opinions…
|
|
Forums
