I know its only 4 weeks, but who is the early vote for offensive ROY? Who do you think will finish as ROY?

Matt Forte

Chris Johnson

Jonathan Stewart

Eddie Royal

DeSean Jackson

I think my vote right now is Forte in a close call over Johnson. Forte IS the offiense in CHI and does everything well.

Who finishes as ROY might be Johnson as Forte might his the wall later in the season and Johnson is kept fresh by splitting with LenDale.

I agree with X, though my edge goes to Johnson for a higher yards per carry average and playing on a team with a better record

Eddie Royal should not be forgotten, I think he's tied for 3rd in the NFL in receptions, so if he stays healthy it's clear the Broncos will give him every opportunity to put up WR2 numbers.

Jackson is out of running just because of his boneheaded play a few weeks ago and his attitude.  Skill is there, but Philly spreads the ball around too much for him to keep this up.

I think it goes

Johnson

Forte

Royal

Slaton (someone who shouln't be forgotten)

Jackson

Stewart

I agree, tied between Forte and Johnson, I wouldn't put Jackson out of it just yet, and I think Stewart is gonna do a shocker game on us soon.

fontaines said:

Jackson is out of running just because of his boneheaded play a few weeks ago and his attitude.  Skill is there, but Philly spreads the ball around too much for him to keep this up.

---

Just blowing smoke, Westbrook did an endzone 1 yard line dive himself, and still got drafted in the first round in almost every league.

North End Dirtdogs said:

Scorpion said:

fontaines said:

Jackson is out of running just because of his boneheaded play a few weeks ago and his attitude.  Skill is there, but Philly spreads the ball around too much for him to keep this up.

---

Just blowing smoke, Westbrook did an endzone 1 yard line dive himself, and still got drafted in the first round in almost every league.

---

It better be smoke because there is a big difference between unselfishness and stupidity!

I guess the point was that if I was voting for ROY and I already had options that were better if not at least equal to Jackson, I would surely vote the other way because i'd be remembering his 1 yard line “fumble”.  Even without that, Jackson is no better than 3rd in most people's minds, so unless he tears it up in the second half of the season he has no chance.  

Also, If anyone noticed, 1 catch for 8 yards today is a sign of how the Eagles have always played….Mcnabb puts up the numbers he does and does not have a good amount of 1000 yard receivers.  I just don't think Jackson will get enough chances to get consistent fantasy numbers

Yeah, I'd say Johson and Forte ate the tops with Royal  and Jackson in the mix. 

I have to go with Forte right now.  He's the Bears offense.  Everything goes thru him.  Chris Johnson is on a really good team.  However, if he wasn't there they would still be a winning team.  Can't be said with Forte.

Slaton is coming on strong with 3 good weeks in a row.  He could push Johnson and Forte.