Need Expert Advice? Get 1-on-1 Fantasy Football Advice Now!

You must be logged in to post

 
Search Forums:


 




Thoughts on trade offer

UserPost

10:07 am
November 14, 2008


ATL_Steevie

Rookie

Loganville, GA

posts 81

1

1 pt per 20 rush yds, 1 pt per 20 receiving yrds, 4 pts per pass TD, 1 pt per 50 passing yards, 6 pts per rush TD, Non-PPR, 20-player rosters.

I am not in play-off contention but need to stay out of the bottom 3 of a deep 12 team dynasty league to not get kicked out of the league.  I am one game out of staying in the league right now and need at least 2 more wins in the next 4 weeks.  My schedule is favorable the rest of the way.

I've been offered:

David Garrard and Zach Miller

for

Cedric Benson and Visanthe Shiancoe

My roster is:

Chad Pennington, Shaun Hill

Lynch, Grant, McFadden, Benson

Evans, Chambers, Ginn, Matt Jones, Moore, Morgan, Ocho, Royal

Scheffler, Shiancoe

His roster is:

Bulger, Garrard, Trent Green, McNabb

Booker, Gore, Turner

Bowe, Branch, C. Davis, Calvin Johnson, Marshall, Randle El, Sweed, Javon Walker

Heath Miller, Zach Miller

I am inclined to accept this as it seems like an upgrade at both positions and I have not yet started Benson in a game since picking him up.  The Jags remaining schedule is tough, though.  Another issue is I would be thinner at RB than I already am. 

Your thoughts, please…


10:18 am
November 14, 2008


Tavaner

Moderator

posts 10003

2

All good offers nee not be accepted if they don’t benefit your team.

Given your situation I’d probably pass on that trade.

Doesn’t sound as if you are inclined to start Garrard over Pennington and I doubt you would start Miller over Scheffler without being forced to. If those premises are true, why make the trade and endager being in the league next year?

11:11 am
November 14, 2008


MrMarbles

Hall of Fame

Ontario, Canada

posts 2772

3

I agree with Tav that the trade is not all that much of an upgrade for you. I’d look elsewhere for a QB upgrade if that is what you really need. I like your RBs and WRs and if Schef is healthy you are looking good at TE

 

About the forum

Currently Online:

nyjetfan

Troy Polamalyourass

abc123

fantasyfreak

10 Guests

Maximum Online: 112

Forums:

Groups: 3

Forums: 10

Topics: 10509

Posts: 87752

Members:

There are 2878 members

There are 78 guests


Smitty has made 6221 posts

Top Posters:

Tavaner - 10003

X - 6641

MrMarbles - 2772

WeekEnd Warriors - 2503

haimez40 - 2383

Administrator: Smitty | Moderators: Smitty, editor, ggarnett, Tavaner, Ballgame, X, Takbax, Yarco, Zach


© Simple:Press Forum - Version 3.1.4 (Build 357)  

Have a fantasy football question ask our staff now! Signup now Xtreme content including rankings, projections, spotlights and more!