Need Expert Advice? Get 1-on-1 Fantasy Football Advice Now!

You must be logged in to post

 
Search Forums:


 




Which Trade is better?

UserPost

1:48 pm
November 12, 2008


jacksands

Rookie

Philadelphia, PA

posts 48

1

I’ve been offered Rodgers and Cotchery for Roddy White and Thigpen, which I think is a great trade for me. Howevery, there’s also the possibility of getting Manning and Welker for McFadden and Royal.

I have one of the top 2 teams, and the 1st possible trade is with another good playoff-bound team, whereas the other trade is with one of the bottom teams. I could really use a franchise QB right now.

12 Team Dynasty, PPR, 1QB, 2/1RB, 3/4WR, TE, K, Def
Thigpen, Schaub
Peterson, Hightower, McFadden, Green-Ellis, Bradshaw, C. Taylor, P. Thomas, Torain
R. Moss, R. White, Royal, Ocho Cinco, D. Thomas, M. Kelly
Witten, Keller
Lindell
Bears Def

2:24 pm
November 12, 2008


X

Moderator

posts 6641

2

I don't know that I could give up White in a dynasty PPR league right now, even with the QB situation you have.  Same with the second deal - Royal has dynasty stud written all over him and I'd be hard pressed to deal that away for a QB upgrade.

I like Rodgers and Manning, don't get me wrong, but QB is less important than top end WRs in this setup.  Thigpen is not playing all that bad right now and I'd even look to the wire for some help - or look at some less expensive QBs to get you through.  There's always other ways to get yourself a decent mid-tier QB with upside other than having to sell off guys like White and Royal (or McFadden for that matter). 

3:39 pm
November 12, 2008


haimez40

Hall of Fame

posts 2382

3

I don't like either of these deals.  No way I trade White right now.

4:07 pm
November 12, 2008


Tavaner

Moderator

posts 10002

4

I’d pass on those trades as well. Thigpen should serve right now and you can use a pick to grab a QB in this years draft.

I would not consider trading any of your players mentioned…and don’t look now but KC has morphed into a passing team. ;)

5:40 pm
November 12, 2008


over_rated_10

Stud

oklahoma

posts 228

5

I dont do either of these trades because White is starting to connect with Matt Ryan and I see fireworks the rest of these season, and seasons to come, same with Royal

10:23 pm
November 12, 2008


fontaines

Stud

posts 404

6

These guys got you covered, no way you give up Royal in a PPR and White is looking like a top-5 dynasty WR for years to come.  I think you'll be suprisingly happy with Thigpen and Schaub for the rest of the year.  Tav is right, KC is airing it out with no regard for anything right now and I think Thigpen will finish the second half of the season as a top-10 QB (bold statement, I know!)

 

About the forum

Currently Online:

Tavaner

nyjetfan

North End Dirtdogs

Scorpion

8 Guests

Maximum Online: 112

Forums:

Groups: 3

Forums: 10

Topics: 10508

Posts: 87742

Members:

There are 2878 members

There are 78 guests


Smitty has made 6221 posts

Top Posters:

Tavaner - 10002

X - 6641

MrMarbles - 2772

WeekEnd Warriors - 2503

haimez40 - 2382

Administrator: Smitty | Moderators: Smitty, editor, ggarnett, Tavaner, Ballgame, X, Takbax, Yarco, Zach


© Simple:Press Forum - Version 3.1.4 (Build 357)  

Have a fantasy football question ask our staff now! Signup now Xtreme content including rankings, projections, spotlights and more!