Just curious who you would prefer as a RB reserve in a full dynasty (we have a positional restriction of 6 RBs max.)

12 team PPR league, full dynasty (starts 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 RB/WR, 1 TE, 1 D/ST, 1 K):

My team:

QB – T.Romo, E.Manning, M.Stafford

RB – A.Peterson, S.Jackson, D.Williams, K.Moreno, D.Brown, W.McGahee

WR – A.Johnson, C.Johnson (DET), S.Smith (CAR), B.Edwards, R.Williams (DAL), D.Henderson, J.Nelson (IR), J.Hardy (IR)

TE – A.Gates, Z.Miller

D/ST – NYG, BAL

K – N.Kaeding

I don't really see either W.McGahee or C.Taylor playing for me even if AP got hurt, so am I better off with McGahee (who is only 28 while Taylor is 30…both are likely to be with different teams next year)??? [I dropped C.Taylor to add W.McGahee...who I was actually shocked was dropped as RBs are hard to come by for many teams]…was this a good move?

I think both moves were good.  McGahee proved earlier this year that he still has some left in the tank and Chester is 2 years older and hasn't been the man for 4 years.  D. Thomas still has a lot to prove before I'll believe that he has the work ethic to be in the league and he has a much worse situation in Washington than Nelson has in GB.

Tavaner said:

If AP ever goes down a lot of guys will realize just how good Taylor is.  m/o.

Plus 1… How quickly we forget what a good back Chester was before ADP arrived and how well he filled in for 2 weeks in 2007 when ADP got hurt.

I haven't forgotten, cause I had Chester as a handcuff in 2007 and have him again this year. He is hogging a very valuable spot on my 15 man roster, but, I am paranoid of cutting him loose. To be honest, my team didn't miss a beat with ADP on the sidelines in 2007.

Incidentally, I also own Rice and really haven't given any thought to handcuffing him, maybe next week, after I am through all my RB bye weeks.