Decided to compile all four dynasty votes into one thread for everyone so it would be easier to compare when we do these again. Before I get to the rankings, I want to thank everyone for the time they took to participate in these. The debates were great and these rankings will be a valuable tool for those preparing for their upcoming dynasty drafts.
I plan on running another round of these sometime in late May to see how the draft and mini-camps have affected the rankings.
Top 10 Dynasty QBs
1. Peyton Manning (thread here)
2. Tom Brady (thread here)
3. Tony Romo (thread here)
4. Carson Palmer (thread here)
5. Drew Brees (thread here)
6. Ben Roethlisberger (thread here)
7. Jay Cutler (thread here)
8. Derek Anderson (thread here)
9. Matt Hasselbeck (thread here)
10. David Garrard (thread here)
Honorable mentions: Eli Manning, Donovan McNabb, Philip Rivers, Matt Shaub
Top 20 Dynasty RB (PPR)
1. Adrian Peterson (thread here)
2. Steven Jackson (thread here)
3. LaDainian Tomlinson (thread here)
4. Joseph Addai (thread here)
5. Brian Westbrook (thread here)
6. Marshawn Lynch (thread here)
7. Frank Gore (thread here)
8. Larry Johnson (thread here)
9. Maurice Jones-Drew (thread here)
10. Willis McGahee (thread here)
11. Marion Barber III (thread here)
12. Clinton Portis (thread here)
13. Darren McFadden (thread here)
14. Reggie Bush (thread here)
15. Michael Turner (thread here)
16. Ryan Grant (thread here)
17. Laurence Maroney (thread here)
18. Ronnie Brown (thread here)
19. Rashard Mendenhall (thread here)
20. Ernest Graham (thread here)
Honorable Mentions: DeAngelo Williams, Jamal Lewis, Willie Parker
Top 20 Dynasty WR (PPR)
1. Reggie Wayne (thread here)
2. Randy Moss (thread here)
3. Andre Johnson (thread here)
4. Larry Fitzgerald (thread here)
5. Marques Colston (thread here)
6. Braylon Edwards (thread here)
7. Steve Smith (thread here)
8. Chad Johnson (thread here)
9. Terrell Owens (thread here)
10. TJ Houshmandzadeh (thread here)
11. Santonio Holmes (thread here)
12. Brandon Marshall (thread here)
13. Anquan Boldin (thread here)
14. Calvin Johnson (thread here)
15. Wes Welker (thread here)
16. Torry Holt (thread here)
17. Plaxico Burress (thread here)
18. Roy Williams (thread here)
19. Greg Jennings (thread here)
20. Dwayne Bowe (thread here)
Honorable Mention: Lee Evans
Top 10 Dynasty TE (PPR)
1. Antonio Gates (thread here)
2. Jason Witten (thread here)
3. Kellen Winslow, Jr. (thread here)
4. Chris Cooley (thread here)
5. Tony Gonzalez (thread here)
6. Tony Scheffler (thread here)
7. Todd Heap (thread here)
8. Dallas Clark (thread here)
9. Vernon Davis (thread here)
10. Heath Miller (thread here)
Honorable mentions: Owen Daniels, Ben Watson
Forums
