25/6/-2, -1 for sacks
1:10:6, PPR

Start QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, flex, TE, DST, PK

Me:

QB - Brees (Matt Ryan, Aaron Rodgers)
RB - Westy, Rice (Pierre Thomas, Chris Perry)
WR - TO, Torry Holt, Cotchery (Nate Burleson, Roddy White)
TE - Witten (Zach Miller)

Him:

QB - DA (McNabb, Cutler)
RB - Gore, Portis, D-Mac (Reggie Bush)
WR - Lee Evans, Devin Hester (Justin Gage)
TE - Todd Heap (Vernon Davis)

Obviously I’m hurting at RB but stacked at WR. He’s pretty well set at RB, but his WRs are laughably poor.

He’s offering the following trade:
I give - Westy, TO, Matt Ryan
I get - Portis, Gore, Lee Evans, Donovan McNabb

Now, I personally think both McNabb and Evans are ridiculously overrated. McNabb wont’ see my roster anyway as I will be starting Brees all season.

Not a big fan of giving up Westy or TO at all, but getting back Portis and Gore is quite nice. I’m pretty darn torn on this one. On one hand, I’m going to have an excellent backfield and even without TO, I still have Holt, Cotchery, Roddy White and Burleson, so it’s not like I’d be hurting.

However, the problem is that I’m giving up the 2 best players in this trade. I’m leaning heavily toward ‘no’

I’d pass…westy better then either of those backs and TO will score morethen the other back. It’s a downgrade for you in a redraft