| User | Post |
|
1:13 am
November 6, 2009
|
electricrelish
Rookie
| | | |
|
| posts 96 |
|
|
Last week, I was offered this trade in a PPR league, but I turned it down. Not sure if I made a mistake, and the owner might still want the trade. Should I take it?
Trade offer:
I give the following:
- Jay Cutler
- Ronnie Brown
- Mike Sims-Walker
- Denver Broncos
He gives up the following:
- Matt Schaub
- Ray Rice
- Mike Wallace
- Minnesota Vikings
We start the following:
1 QB
1-3 RB (.5 per reception)
2-4 WR (1 pt per reception)
1-3 TE (TE's get 1.5 per reception)
1 PK
1 Def
Pros:
Schaub is a better QB
Cons:
Schaub faces the Colts twice and he has a bye week.
My thinking was that I lose Schaub for Week 10, when I would play this other owner, and he has 2 tough match-ups against the Colts. But now I'm thinking Cutler isn't that good. But, Also, I recently lost Owen Daniels, so I might need to keep Sims-Walker to help makeup the difference. With Crabtree coming on, I could start 4 WRs. Plus, I like Ronnie Brown's end of year schedule better. I was thinking of offering back the same trade, but without Brown and Rice. I also thought I'd like the Seahawks D more than the Vikings based on more favorable matchups left, and I can alternate by playing the Saints. Thoughts? Rosters listed below.
My Current Team (5-3)
- Jay Cutler
- Mike Bell
- Ronnie Brown
- Michael Bush
- Reggie Bush
- Michael Crabtree
- Pierre Garcon
- Andre Johnson
- Mike Sims-Walker
- Reggie Wayne
- Dustin Keller
- Marcedes Lewis
- Ben Watson
- John Carney
- Denver Broncos
- New Orleans Saints
His Team (4-4)
- Matt Schuab
- Ahmad Bradshaw
- Willis McGahee
- Ray Rice
- Michael Turner
- Carnell Williams
- Dwayne Bowe
- Malcom Floyd
- Brandon Marshall
- Mike Wallace
- Roddy White
- Fred Davis
- Tony Scheffler
- Olindo Mare
- Seattle Seahawks
- Minnesotta Vikings
|
|
|
7:47 am
November 6, 2009
|
Tavaner
Moderator
| | | |
|
| posts 13800 |
|
|
|
8:50 am
November 6, 2009
|
Keeper Rook
Rookie
| | | |
|
| posts 110 |
|
|
I would take it. Bye weeks are not as important with your current record. I think Rice is an upgrade from Brown – Ricky is taking too many opportunities away from Ronnie in that offense and Rice has not found a matchup he didn't like. Sims-Walker to Wallace is obviously a downgrade, but you can't get something without giving something.
|
|
|
4:30 am
November 7, 2009
|
jamesmorgan222
Elite User
| | Austin | |
|
| posts 587 |
|
|
i would take it. the upgrade from Cutler to Schaub is worth it alone. Schaubs schedule is much much better. Colts secondary is reeling with injuries.
|
|
|
5:23 am
November 7, 2009
|
JRMRRT
Hall of Fame
| | | |
|
| posts 3136 |
|
|
Schaub > Cutler
Rice > Brown
Wallace < Sims-Walker
Vikings > Broncos (IMO)
You win 3-1…I would make that trade.
|
|
|
2:07 pm
November 9, 2009
|
mrod
Rookie
| | | |
|
| posts 183 |
|
|
i do it in a hearbeat..please see my positng ..good luck and thanks
|
|
|
6:20 pm
November 9, 2009
|
nyjetfan
Rookie
| | | |
|
| posts 117 |
|
|
Tavaner said:
Pass.
I too would make that trade. You've got more than enough talent at WR to part with Siims-Walker.
Why not, Tav?
|
|
|
12:56 am
November 10, 2009
|
electricrelish
Rookie
| | | |
|
| posts 96 |
|
|
Thanks for the input everyone. I'm still mulling it over. I really like Ronnie Brown's upcoming schedule. Brown really only has one difficult matchup in the next seven weeks, although Houston has gotten better. Rice has a slightly more difficult schedule having to face Pittsburgh twice. If I wasn't losing Schaub for week, and going against the player who I am trading with in Week 10, then I would jump on it, but I'm hestitant. It may be too late now. He may have changed his mind. One thing for sure, it makes his team better because his WR corp is not that strong, but his running game is with Michael Turner.
R. Brown
- W10 TB
- W11 CAR
- W12 Buf
- W13 NE
- W14 JAC – Playoffs
- W15 TEN – Playoffs
- W16 HOU – Championship
R. Rice
W10 CLE
W11 IND
W12 PIT
W13 GB
W14 DET – Playoffs
W15 CHI – Playoffs
W16 PIT – Championsip
|
|
Forums
